Searching , Google Vs Facebook

After having watched Mark Zuckerberg’s two part interview on youtube, i was wondering what would, searching the same thing ( “seagate Goflex” ) on both the platforms (facebook and Google) would result in.

Side by side, the search term on google , facebook , bing (apparently facebook has some tie-up with M$)

OK , some of my observations ( please do share your observations too ! ) :

1. Google is good with Factual data.

2. Facebook has an added advantage with it knowing what my friends , other facebook users’ and i like . And how many of the users’ like / dislike / have commented on the topic i am searching. For the factual data , its using Bing (M$ ‘s search engine).

3. Bing is a reasonable search engine, i have nothing to say about it .

THE MOST IMPORTANT OBSERVATION :

4. Though Facebook uses Bing for its search, the Bing results Facebook displays on its search page are significantly different. I think Facebook does its own filtering on top of Bing results , to filter out results like following :

  • FreeAgent® GoFlex™

    Complete all three stages and stand to win the FreeAgent® GoFlex™ Family and Full HD 42 inch LCD TV. Contest closes 28 June 2010. Play now! FreeAgent® GoFlex™. Meet the world …

    seagategoflex.com · Cached page
  • seagate goflex : seagate goflex – Cheap, Discount and FREE Super …

    seagate goflex – Cheap, Discount and FREE Super Saver Shipping

    seagategoflex.blogspot.com · Cached page

The first of the above results from Bing, is quite relevant to my search string (“seagate Goflex”) its the official site of the product. Here both Facebook and Google missed it.

My motivation for the blog post is that , many search providers are coming in the market, each with their own way of looking at the problem of search. All are trying to do their best. But none of them IMHO are actually showing me what “I WANT TO SEE”.

They (search engines) should understand what i am searching for (in this case a product) and give me most relevant information first ( in this case, the price in and around where i live , the technical specs etc , they should ask some more questions to refine their search results ) .

Both google and facebook have the means (personal data) to understand about me and should strive to give personalized search results. With an option of “Factual Search” which is also very important. Facebook’s positive point is that, it gives me very few searches with some degree of personalization (what my friends think about it) . When i search for a text , i am not going to look through millions of pages that google shows me but only a few say about 10 to 20 most “relevant” results.

Both Google and Facebook should learn from each other. And M$ should focus on the one thing it has managed to do fairly good , make an operating system 😉 (Humor intended). It would be fun to see what future of search has in store for us !

Until next time !

LIVE LONG & PROSPER.

Kunal Ghosh

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Searching , Google Vs Facebook

  1. I’d look at the whole issue in another way and use a work around to give anonymity to my search…the concept of handing my personal privacy to any company is objectionable in the extreme.

    Consider also that the US government has brought in the first “thought crime legislation” so that even searching fo0r something could be construed as an illegal act http://www.dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=18815

    Anonymity can be had by use of services such as Scroogle http://www.scroogle.org/ will do for most people but if you don’t want to trust the anonymising provider then that is a little more difficult but can be done.

    Giving your privacy away is a bad idea…period.

    • Hi david,
      First up, i agree with you 100 percent.
      But again the fact is social networking sites are very successful because
      majority of people do not share our love for freedom and privacy.

      That said, i did not know about scroogle.org ,thanks for letting me know !

  2. Pingback: Tweets that mention Searching , Google Vs Facebook « ETA → ∞ -- Topsy.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s